ROMA ARCHEOLOGICA & RESTAURO ARCHITETTURA 2020. Paolo Giorgio Ferri, Hunter of Looted Antiquities, Dies at 72 – A prosecutor in Italy, he dismantled multinational trafficking rings. NYT (20/06/2020), ARCAblog (11/06/2020) & Finestre sull’Arte (21/06/2020).
1). ROME – Paolo Giorgio Ferri, Hunter of Looted Antiquities, Dies at 72. A prosecutor in Italy, he dismantled multinational trafficking rings, recovering tens of thousands of Greco-Roman artifacts worth hundreds of millions of dollars. THE NEW YORK TIMES (20/06/2020).
When the Italian prosecutor Paolo Giorgio Ferri visited the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 2004, he posed for a picture beside an ancient terracotta mixing bowl so rare and celebrated that it had held pride of place in the Met’s Greek and Roman galleries for 32 years. Four years later, as a result of Mr. Ferri’s dogged work as an investigator and antiquities hunter with Rome’s Ministry of Cultural Heritage, that object, known as the Euphronios krater, was back on Italian soil, as were scores of other looted treasures that had been acquired by American museums and collectors since the 1960s. Mr. Ferri, who had recently retired after 45 years as a judicial magistrate, public prosecutor and legal consultant, died on June 14 at a hospital in Rome. He was 72. His family said the cause was a heart attack.
Colleagues say his legacy includes dismantling multinational looting and trafficking rings; recovering tens of thousands of Greco-Roman artifacts from secret storehouses; and compelling what is sometimes called “the great giveback,” a period that began in 2006 and continues to this day, during which American museums have returned at least 120 ill-gotten antiquities valued at more than $1 billion to the Greek and Italian authorities.
“No one before him had used the courts to attack the art predators and big museums and corrupt dealers,” said Fabio Isman, his friend and biographer. “He was very stubborn, and what he did was very daring.”
In an email interview with The New York Times last year, Mr. Ferri said he did not know what to expect in 1994 when he began investigating the theft of a statue from a villa in Rome and its sudden appearance at a Sotheby’s auction in London. After much digging, he said, he discovered that a dozen prominent American museums housed Roman and Etruscan items that Italian officials never knew existed. His list eventually grew to 47 museums worldwide.
“It took several years to have a complete panorama of what happened to the Italian cultural patrimony,” Mr. Ferri said. “When I was fully aware of the damages caused by the criminals, I was really furious.”
As the public prosecutor in Rome, overseeing criminal cases for the Italian Ministry of Culture, he embarked on what turned out to be a 17-year period of subpoenas, raids, arrests and trials. After a “steep learning curve,” he said, he also started working with the United States attorney’s office in Manhattan to press his investigation into American museums and art brokers.
His big breakthrough came in September 1995, when he arranged for the Italian and Swiss police to raid a building run by a renowned Italian art dealer, Giacomo Medici. The building sat inside the Geneva Free Port, a sprawling commercial district where international goods can be stored, purchased and sold with virtually no oversight, and often free of taxes and duties.
Their haul was astonishing. Investigators found thousand of pieces of Greek, Roman and Etruscan art; binders filled with sales records and letters between Mr. Medici and dealers and curators in London and New York; and hundreds of annotated Polaroid photographs of objects that had clearly been pillaged.
The photos showed pitchers and vases, stone busts and burial relics, bronze statues of animals and gods, and other black-market objects. The items were still encrusted with soil from when they had been dug up, and the notations on the pictures indicated their origins. There were even follow-up images of the items after they had been cleaned and restored and made ready for the art market.
“When I first saw it,” Mr. Ferri recalled, “I compared the Medici warehouse to Ali Baba’s cave.” Indeed, among the Medici Polaroids were images of the Met’s 2,500-year-old krater, which is decorated with scenes from “The Iliad” by a master Greek artist named Euphronios.
The discovery of the so-called Medici archive precipitated a string of raids, trials and legal claims that exposed two more major antiquities traffickers: Gianfranco Becchina, an Italian art broker, and Robin Symes, a London fine arts dealer. Both were found to have immense troves of looted Greco-Roman items — Mr. Becchina in Basel, Switzerland, and Mr. Symes on the remote Greek island of Schinoussa — and both had kept dossiers detailing where the objects originated and to whom they had been sold.
Mr. Ferri convicted Mr. Medici in 2004 in one of many cases he brought against an expanding network of antiquities smugglers. He also made a bold move that rattled the American art world: He indicted two prominent museum figures, the curator Marion True and the collector and dealer Robert E. Hecht Jr., for trafficking in Medici’s looted art.
Paparazzi photos of Ms. True, the longtime antiquities curator at the J. Paul Getty Museum in Los Angeles, being swarmed outside a Rome courthouse were widely published amid allegations that she had illegally acquired dozens of objects for the Getty. (Ms. True has long denied the charges and said her case was a show trial.)
Mr. Hecht was accused of purchasing the Euphronios krater directly from Mr. Medici knowing it was plunder, and of manufacturing an innocent background story before selling it to the Met for $1 million in 1972.
Although Mr. Ferri’s charges against Mr. Hecht (who died in 2012) and Ms. True were dismissed under statutes of limitations in 2010 and 2012, they had alarmed American museum directors, who had never seen criminal charges brought against those individuals entrusted with obtaining their antiquities.
From 2006 to 2011, the Met returned 20 Roman objects in addition to the krater, the Getty gave back 47, and the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston repatriated 13. Museums in Dallas, Cleveland and Toledo, Ohio, also gave up Greco-Roman objects, as did merchants like the Royal Athena Gallery in New York and collectors like the philanthropist Shelby White.
Italian officials continue to pursue scores of items they recognize from the looters’ dossiers whenever auction houses and dealers put them on the market.
“Paolo Ferri opened a road, and we hope it will not be abandoned,” Mr. Isman said.
Paolo Giorgio Ferri was born in Rome on Oct. 17, 1947. He earned his undergraduate and law degrees from Sapienza University of Rome and became a judge magistrate in 1977 and a public prosecutor a decade later. By the early 1990s, his interest in classical history had led him to a position with the Cultural Ministry, which was beginning to tackle the scourge of antiquities crime. He remained in that role for the next 20 years.
Mr. Ferri is survived by his wife, Marita, and a daughter, Sofia. Friends said he had recently renovated a seafront apartment in the Sardinian city of Alghero and hoped to spend his time scuba diving and spearfishing.
In his interview with The Times, Mr. Ferri said he was glad that colleagues were continuing the hunt for plundered objects showcasing classical Rome’s glory and sophistication. But he was also wistful.
“The few refunds that have occurred concern perhaps 3 percent of what was taken,” he said. “They have above all just a symbolic value.”
Fabiana Di Fazio contributed reporting from Rome.
Fonte / source:
— Paolo Giorgio Ferri, 72, Who Recovered Tens of Thousands of Looted Antiquities. THE NEW YORK TIMES (22/06/2020):B12.
2). ROME – Remembering Paolo Giorgio Ferri. ARCAblog (11/06/2020).
It is with profound sadness that ARCA shares the news of today’s passing of Paolo Giorgio Ferri, Italy’s famed Sostituto Procuratore della Repubblica a Roma due to health complications. He was 72 years old.
Dr. Ferri’s first investigative case into Italy’s stolen heritage began in 1994 and involved a statue stolen from Rome’s Villa Torlonia that was then sold at auction by Sotheby’s. But it was the invaluable role he played in doggedly pursuing corrupt antiquities dealers who laundered antiquities into some of the world’s most prestigious museums that made his name famous among those who follow art and heritage crimes.
Forty-eight when his investigation began into the activities of Giacomo Medici, Gianfranco Becchina, Robin Symes and others, Paolo was integral in truly exposing the ugly underbelly of the ancient art trade and the insidious phenomenon of laundering cultural goods.
In February 2000 Judge Ferri received a commendation and a formal expression of esteem from General Roberto Conforti (then Commanding Officer of the Carabinieri Department for the Protection of the Italian Cultural Heritage) for the suggestions he made in relation to a project initiative to change the Italian law on cultural goods. In 2011 ARCA honored Dr. Ferri with an art crime protection award for his role in the 2005 case against Emanuel Robert Hecht and Marion True, the former curator of the J Paul Getty Museum. This case, and his work on it, marked a dramatic change, in years to come, in the policy of acquisitions by museums around the world, as well as set the stage for numerous restitutions of stolen artifacts to their countries of origin.
Following his career as a prosecutor, Ferri continued to fight for Italy’s heritage and served on a special commission with Italy’s Ministry of Culture, created for the restitution of national cultural heritage stolen abroad. There he served as a legal advisor on cultural diplomacy negotiations. Ferri also provided legal opinions regarding criminal matters, served as an advisor to ICCROM, was part of a commission for the criminal reform of the Code of Cultural Heritage, and participated in Vienna in the drafting of Guidelines to the United Nations Convention against transnational organized crime, which was signed in Palermo in 2000.
Dr. Ferri will be remembered by his colleagues and friends as one who never backed off in the fight against illicit trafficking and as someone always willing to share his knowledge and legal expertise freely and openly. Journalist Fabio Isman, who broke the news to some of us, recalled that when Dr. Ferri wrote his first Letters Rogatory, it took three weeks to draft the document. At the height of his investigations Ferri would go on to write three Letters Rogatory a week, asking the world for judicial assistance in the restitution of Italy’s stolen works of art.
ARCA wishes to offer its support and condolences to everyone close to this wonderful man, but most importantly to Paolo’s family, particularly his wife Mariarita, his daughter Sofia and his grandchildren.
Foto / fonte / source: Paolo Giorgio Ferri – Image Credit: Daniela Rizzo / Maurizio Pelligrini, friends and colleagues. Maurizio Pelligrini relates that this photo was taken 28 September 2004, when Paolo was in New York and still did not know if Italy would be able to convince the director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Philippe de Montebello to destitute the famous Euphronios crater; & ARCAblog (11/06/2020).
Fonte / source:
— ARCAblog (11/06/2020).
3). ROMA – Addio a Paolo Giorgio Ferri, il giudice che combatteva i criminali dell’arte. Finestre sull’Arte (21/06/2020).
— ROMA ARCHEOLOGICA & RESTAURO ARCHITETTURA 2020. The Metropolitan Museum of Art & the Monteleone Chariot “La Biga Rapita” – Historical & Contemporary Documentation Relevant to the Controversy between the Metropolitan Museum and the Comune di Monteleone di Spoleto (2008). . Foto & stampa.